{
  "schema": "naguard.open-handoff-card.v1",
  "author": "陈鹏旭",
  "version": "2026-10-16-closing-13",
  "status": "open-proposal-not-assigned",
  "newExperimentExecuted": false,
  "coreQuestion": "最终验收结果一致时，检查点减少的重做，是否抵得过保存、全输入核验以及接入维护代价？",
  "questionStatus": "Formulated for the next phase after the existing observations; not a preregistered success rule for old experiments",
  "existingAnswer": "One controlled boundary observed 4 fewer logical checks; no established net time, energy, user or commercial benefit.",
  "supportedStartingPoint": {
    "kind": "reproduce-frozen-own-site-template",
    "files": 67,
    "protocol": {
      "path": "evidence/reality-loop-protocol.json",
      "sha256": "9bc84e5768aa7271a09a06882fe223ee71ca7f0830077602735b86919696870c"
    },
    "inputManifest": {
      "path": "evidence/reality-loop-manifest.json",
      "sha256": "9ab497d23c3666de82f2851f00c9cf52cc96e65fe1aa6d46be98726f80eab442"
    },
    "package": {
      "path": "evidence/reality-loop.zip",
      "sha256": "f1a6fbf9a67b871a68ea24e0c4c52b1c7be9ab45f41d7815d6569bbfe427205a"
    },
    "guide": "evidence/reality-loop-readme.md",
    "normalReferenceDigest": "a40d56591726c39d15197b0ab2bb3077c21bf18b62586dc03cf3e6cfd0cd437b",
    "interruption": "own-child-process-exit-75-after-four-committed-tasks",
    "scope": "Fixed package only. Fresh directory per run; do not substitute a private directory or freeze a changed input and call it a replication."
  },
  "baseline": "ordinary restart from beginning, same final acceptance and task quality",
  "requiredReturnArtifacts": [
    "Unmodified protocol and input manifest, with SHA-256",
    "Original results.json and derived results-corrected.json; retain original cost bug and correction provenance",
    "Raw worker/controller events and verification.json",
    "Final reports and accepted outputs",
    "Failure, rejection, ties and worse outcomes; do not report only successful conditions",
    "Operator runtime/OS, run order, interruption boundary and any differences"
  ],
  "sourceAcceptance": {
    "browserReportSchema": "naguard.reality-loop.results.v1",
    "maxBytes": 5242880,
    "import": "Browser-memory display only; no upload or task execution",
    "hashCaution": "Importer checks digest string format, not the actual source events or identity. Matching strings are not source authentication.",
    "humanReviewRequired": true
  },
  "nextAdaptation": {
    "status": "not implemented",
    "templateName": null,
    "protocolVersion": null,
    "contributor": null,
    "reviewer": null,
    "requirement": "A new workflow needs an explicit adapter, frozen inputs, quality reference, failure conditions and own protocol before running. Current importer is not a universal experiment interface."
  },
  "measurementsToCollectSeparately": [
    {
      "name": "finalQuality",
      "unit": "same acceptance rules",
      "required": true,
      "value": null
    },
    {
      "name": "repeatedWork",
      "unit": "supported task attempts",
      "required": true,
      "value": null
    },
    {
      "name": "endToEndWallTime",
      "unit": "ms including startup, full hashing, saves, restart and final verification",
      "required": true,
      "value": null
    },
    {
      "name": "integrationAndMaintenance",
      "unit": "person-minutes with explicit method",
      "required": true,
      "value": null
    },
    {
      "name": "actualEnergy",
      "unit": "Wh with meter/method/conditions",
      "required": false,
      "value": null
    }
  ],
  "decisionRules": [
    "Final report or accepted output differs: no successful recovery claim.",
    "Input/version binding differs: reject reuse and record why.",
    "Compare costs in their stated units; do not add milliseconds, Wh and money without a justified conversion model.",
    "If complete measured cost outweighs avoided rework, retain ordinary restart; preserve a tie or negative result.",
    "One fixed-order observation does not establish performance or energy superiority."
  ],
  "cooperation": {
    "maintainer": "陈鹏旭",
    "contributor": null,
    "reviewer": null,
    "assigned": false,
    "entry": "Publish reproducible, authorized-to-share artifacts in the existing 1836 project for human review. This card does not send messages or automatically register collaborators."
  },
  "commercialHypothesis": {
    "status": "unvalidated",
    "possibleSmallDeliverable": "One explicitly scoped, supported check with reviewable output and acceptance criteria",
    "price": null,
    "order": null,
    "payment": null,
    "condition": "Only discuss a service after a real counterpart confirms need and acceptance; the website currently performs no transaction."
  },
  "notes": [
    "No battery-pack parameters, Wh measurements, AI inference or new user interviews added.",
    "Contributor identity, authority, publication scope and responsibility must be explicitly agreed; empty fields are unknown, not consent."
  ]
}